Birth Trauma in the Eye of the Beholder Critique

The phenomenon of interest (birth trauma and what it means to women) was clearly identified in the report. In the introduction the authors stated that women’s perception of birth trauma is quite different from the perception of the same phenomenon by health care providers. She also uses a term â€Å"in the eyes of the beholder† to emphasize that for every woman this phenomenon is unique. It is stated that PTSD after childbirth is quite prevalent and several studies support this fact. However, research is regarding the understanding of the birth trauma phenomenon from the woman’s experience lacking. The problem statement was worded clearly and directly and I wasn’t ambivalent about what problem will be discussed in the remainder of the article.†¦show more content†¦One letter informed members of a study. The researchers wrote the second letter explaining the role of the woman in the study and the research program. Several women sent their personal journals chronicling their traumatic birth experiences and the PTSD. Most of the participants chose to participate over the Internet and sent their story as an attachment. In phenomenological studies, in-depth conversations are the main data source. Researchers help informants to describe lived experiences without leading the discussion (Beck, 2012). In my opinion it was fully achieved with the use of personal stories and personal journals. As was mentioned above, the data collection focused on human experience and I believe the subjects were protected in this study. This study was approved by university’s institutional review board and participants were provided with informed consent. The author used Colaizzi’s method of data analysis. She did a great job explaining the procedures used to analyze the data. The analysis of the data in this study began with the reading of the stories and journals. The researcher extracted significant statements and formulated the meanings for those statements. The information was then further broken down into cluster of 4 themes. The process of saturation was reached when no further categories could be formed. Then, the findings were integrated into description of phenomenon and validated by nineShow MoreRelatedSave the Children Campaign, the Analysis2476 Words   |  10 Pagesnight, we cannot wait. Today, Save the Children is recognized as a leading independent child-assistance agency creating real and lasting change for children in need in 12 states and in more than 40 developing countries (Shriver). Analysis and Critique The use of Ethos: OKeefe defines the concept of ethos as judgments made by a perceiver concerning the believability of a communicator (Gass 76). Other important features of credibility include that it is a multidimensional construct, meaningRead MoreOrganisational Theory230255 Words   |  922 Pagespostmodernism anything new? The history Post-industrialism and the information society The virtual organization Neo-fordism, flexible specialization and post-fordism The regulation school Institutionalist school The ‘managerialist’ school The flexible firm – critique Postmodern organizations – the work of Stewart Clegg and Paul Heydebrand Conclusions 198 198 200 202 205 206 211 213 215 217 220 225 227 234 Chapter 6 Postmodernism as a philosophy: the ultimate challenge to organization theory? IntroductionRead MoreContemporary Issues in Management Accounting211377 Words   |  846 Pagesorganizations (see Chapman and Chua 2003 for a discussion). However, the advances anticipated have frequently been far more limited in scale and scope than hoped for. The following excerpt taken from the beginning of perhaps the most high-proWle and detailed critique of management accounting work shares the understanding that performance management involves more than better technical systems for the quantiWcation of, and reporting on, activity: The computing revolution of the past two decades has so reducedRead MoreStephen P. Robbins Timothy A. Judge (2011) Organizational Behaviour 15th Edition New Jersey: Prentice Hall393164 Words   |  1573 Pagesactually more likely to target their own sex, though to a less dramatic degree than female bullies do. Finally, it does appear that women are more adversely affected by bullying. A recent study of 183 victims of bullying found that the prevalence of trauma was higher for women (49 percent) than men (35 percent). The complexity of these relationships shows us that gaining a true understanding of organizational behavior phenomena often means understanding that the causes and consequences of work behavior